Whitesell-Somers Family Web Project - Person Sheet
Whitesell-Somers Family Web Project - Person Sheet
NameBenjamin SIMPSON [35748]
BirthJul 9, 1769, Chowan County, North Carolina [35749]
DeathOct 10, 1837, Putnam County, Indiana [35748]
BurialManhattan Cemetery, Manhattan, Putnam County, Indiana [35749]
Spouses
BirthJan 19, 1772, Chowan County, North Carolina [35750]
Death1812, Orange County, North Carolina [35749], [35750]
BurialUnknown [35750]
MarriageJan 27, 1791, Chowan County, North Carolina [35750]
ChildrenLemuel Wilson (1794-1881)
 Sarah Sallie (-1849)
Birthabt 1780, North Carolina [35751]
Death1860, Indiana [35751]
BurialUnknown [35751]
MarriageMay 9, 1813, Orange County, North Carolina [35749], [35751]
Obituary Online notes for Benjamin SIMPSON
Benjamin Swain Simpson was born 9 July 1769 in Chowan County, North Carolina, son of Samuel and Mary Swain Simpson. Sam recorded the births of his children on the flyleaf of his Kirk of Scotland catechism, which found its way into his Revolutionary War Pension application file.

Ben was first married to Mary Wyatt who bore him at least 4 children before her death circa 1812-13. His second wife was Margaret Garrison whom he married in 1813 in Orange County, NC. Ben appears on the 1800, 1810 and 1820 Census of Orange County.

Ben's son-in-law, Abraham Lewis, came to Indiana in 1822 and purchased land in Putnam County (Bureau of Land Management-General Land Office Records). He then appears to have returned to NC and convinced his father-in-law to move to Indiana, too. In the mid 1820's Ben Simpson and Abe Lewis sell their land in Orange County NC to Ben's oldest son, Lemuel W. Simpson (Orange County land records). Ben and Abe then appear on the 1830 Census of Putnam County.

In 1838, Ben's son Ben (who is on the 1830 Census still in Orange County) arrives in Putnam and buys land. Beginning in 1837, Ben's sons Jacob, Luke and Zimri also buy land in Putnam County (BLM-GLO Records). However, in 1840, Ben the elder is not on the Census, but Margaret Simpson is listed as the head of a household. She also appears twice on the 1850 Census of Putnam, once in step-son Luke's household, the other in son Jacob's household. (She lived with both Jacob and Zimri and probably died in the late 1850's at Zimri's home near Russiaville, Indiana.)

Ben's grandson, Henry Simpson, left an extensive biographic sketch in the 1883 History and Biographic Sketches of Woodford County, Illinois outlining the family's migration from North Carolina the the midwest.

Maps of early land purchase in the Putnam County Library show the Simpson properties were about a mile south and west of the village of Manhatten.

It appears that all of Ben's children moved to other places, with the exception of his daughter Mary "Polly" Simpson Lewis. She, husband Abraham and several of their children are bured in the Boone-Hutcheson Cemetery, a few miles north of Manhatten.

Finally, the descendents of Ben's sons have no record that any of them had sons named Ben - with the exception of Jacob, who's son Benjamin S. Simpson is buried in the Olio Township Cemetery at Eureka (Woodford County) Illinois. [35749]
Obituary Online notes for Mary (Spouse 1)
Mary Wyatt was born to Joshua Wyatt and Elizabeth Scrimshire Wyatt on 19 January 1772, in Chowan County North Carolina.

She was the second of six known children.

She married Benjamin Swain Simpson on 27 January 1791 in Chowan County; they were the parents of Lemuel, Sarah, Benjamin, Mary. and Luke.

Mary died about 1812. After she died, her husband Benjamin remarried to Margaret Garrison in May of 1813.

The exact details of Mary's death and burial are unknown.
[35750]
Obituary Online notes for Margaret (Spouse 2)
Margaret Garrison was born about 1780, in North Carolina. Her parents are unknown. She married Benjamin Swain Simpson on 9 May 1813 in Orange County; she was Benjamin's second wife. They were the parents of Jacob, Zimmerah, and George.

Margaret died about 1860, in Indiana; Benjamin had died 23 years earlier, in 1837.

The exact details of Margaret's death and burial are unknown.
Last Modified Apr 19, 2024Created Nov 10, 2026 by Terry M. Whitesell, using Reunion for Macintosh
Created Nov 10, 2026 by Terry M. Whitesell
Created using a Macintosh computer and Reunion software.

© WhitesellSomers.com

"This information is provided for the free use of those engaged in non-commercial genealogical research.
Any commercial use is prohibited."